Skip to main content
Aired fall 2011 · The CW · returning contestants, Greece finale stretch

The All Stars

Cycle 17 departs from the standard format entirely — the competing cast is drawn entirely from returning contestants across prior cycles rather than new talent. Greece provides the international backdrop for the finale stretch.

Filmed
Los Angeles, California; Athens, Greece
Premiered
Sep 14, 2011
Episodes
13
Format
Modeling competition · all-returnee cast
fan favorites and prior finalists returning
Cast size
14 players
Fourteen returning contestants from prior cycles
Host
Tyra Banks
seventeenth season at the helm
On this page5 sections
  1. 01The take
  2. 02The shape of the season
  3. 03Where it sits in the canon
  4. 04Adjacent in the canon
  5. 05Also appears in
01The take

Reunion energy, not discovery.

An entertaining novelty that functions more as a reunion special than a genuine competition.
02The shape of the season

Fourteen returning contestants, zero rookies this cycle.

Cycle 17 is the show's first full departure from its own format — every contestant is a returning alumna, making the season feel closer to a victory-lap reunion than a competition for working modeling contracts. Greece's coastal settings give the photoshoot legs genuine visual texture. The trade-off is that the stakes feel different when the cast already knows the format and each other. Enjoyable for invested fans of prior cycles; less meaningful as a competition season.

03Where it sits in the canon

The #21 slot.

Slot #21 of 24 in the America's Next Top Model Editor's Canon. Cycle 17 is the show's most significant structural departure, and the departure is the source of both its appeal and its limitations. Every contestant is a returning alumna, removing the discovery premise at the core of the format and replacing it with a dynamic closer to a celebrity reunion. Greece's coastal locations give the photoshoot legs genuine visual texture, and the returnee cast brings a range of recognizable personalities for committed fans. The format change is interesting as a one-cycle experiment; as a competition, the stakes feel fundamentally different.

No spoilers. Every page is reviewed before it goes live.
05Also appears in

Cross-references.