On this page
A new center of gravity.
A new critical voice at the judging table gives the format a second-act energy it had been missing since the Stern years peaked.
Cowell joins, panel resets again.
Simon Cowell's arrival resets the panel's center of gravity. Where Howard Stern brought a radio broadcaster's precision, Cowell brings an industry executive's instincts — sharper on commercial viability, more direct about what works at scale. Mel B, Howie Mandel, and Heidi Klum provide range alongside him. The audition pool benefits from a judge with different calibration. A panel overhaul in a settled format produces friction that keeps the open-call promise honest. Fresh footing in a familiar frame.
The #11 slot.
Slot #11 of 21 in the America's Got Talent Editor's Canon. Season eleven opens the Simon Cowell era, and the panel reset is the season's defining story. Cowell replaces Howard Stern — two very different critical voices — and brings an industry executive's calibration to a table shaped by Stern's broadcaster instincts. Mel B, Howie Mandel, and Heidi Klum provide a full four-way dynamic with genuine contrast across disciplines and instincts. The Stern era produced the format's golden-buzzer standard; the Cowell era recalibrates what the judging table values. A strong first argument from a new voice at the table.
6 moments, no spoilers.
- Premiere · a Golden Buzzer for Nessun Dorma
Mel B presses her buzzer for 13-year-old opera singer Laura Bretan's rendition of 'Nessun Dorma' — Simon Cowell's opening reaction as a new judge sets the tone for his tenure.
- Auditions · a ukulele original
Howie Mandel's buzzer goes to singer-songwriter Grace VanderWaal, performing an original song on ukulele.
- Auditions · a crooner's standard
Heidi Klum's buzzer goes to jazz vocalist Sal Valentinetti, performing a Sinatra standard.
- Auditions · Cowell's first-ever Golden Buzzer
Simon Cowell presses his first buzzer in the role, for teenage singer Calysta Bevier.
- Auditions · the host breaks the rules
Nick Cannon presses his own buzzer for nonagenarian burlesque performer Dorothy Williams after being told every judge buzzer was already used — his only buzzer press across his entire hosting run.
- Format · a new stage
The live rounds move from Radio City Music Hall to the Dolby Theatre in Los Angeles this season.